From the NICHD Annual Report:
In vivo MRI histology
We aim to develop novel next-generation in vivo MRI methods to better understand brain structure and organization in normal and abnormal development, disease, degeneration, and trauma. The most mature technology that we invented and developed is Diffusion Tensor MRI (DTI), by which we measure a diffusion tensor of water, D, voxel-by-voxel within an imaging volume. Information derived from this quantity includes white matter fiber–tract orientation, the mean-squared distance that water molecules diffuse in each direction, the orientationally averaged mean diffusivity, and other scalar (invariant) quantities that are intrinsic to the tissue and independent of the experiment. The parameters behave like quantitative histological 'stains' even though they are obtained from endogenous tissue water non-invasively and are 'developed' without exogenous contrast agents or dyes. The bulk or orientationally averaged diffusivity is the most successful DTI parameter proposed to date and is widely used to identify ischemic regions in the brain during acute stroke, as well as for many other indications. Our measures of diffusion anisotropy (e.g., the "Fractional Anisotropy" or FA) are universally used to follow changes in normally and abnormally developing white matter, including dysmyelination and demyelination. Our group also pioneered the use of fiber direction–encoded color (DEC) maps to display the orientation of the main association, projection, and commissural white matter pathways in the brain. To assess anatomical connectivity among various cortical brain areas, we also proposed and developed DTI "Streamline" Tractography.
Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) directionally-encoded color (DEC) maps computed from age-specific average brains. Registration was performed using a novel diffeomorphic transformation framework. Two types of DTI templates are now available for download (https://ndar.nih.gov/edit_collection.html?id=1151) from the database: morphologically faithful templates, which represent the average morphology of the subjects included in each age group (top row), and morphologically normalized templates in which the average brain is further warped to the morphology of the 18–20 year old group (bottom row).
More recently, we invented and developed more advanced in vivo MR methods to measure fine-microstructural features of axons and fascicles, which previously could only be measured optically using laborious ex vivo histological methods. We are developing efficient means for performing "k and q-space MRI" in the living brain, the most recent of which is "Mean Apparent Propagator" (MAP) MRI. The approach can detect subtle microstructural and architectural features in both gray and white matter at a finer spatial resolution than can DTI and also subsumes DTI, as well as providing a bevy of new in vivoquantitative 'stains' to measure and map. We can also use MAP-MRI to characterize features of 'anomalous' or fractal diffusion that we recently observed in the neuropil, which consists of a patchwork of interwoven dendrites and axons and of neuroglial cells in the gray matter of the central nervous system. We also developed a family of diffusion MRI methods to enable us to 'drill down into the voxel' and measure features such as average axon diameter (AAD) and axon diameter distribution (ADD) within large white-matter fascicles, dubbing the methods CHARMED and AxCaliber MRI, respectively. After careful validation studies, we reported the first in vivo measurement of ADDs within the rodent corpus callosum. The ADD is important neurophysiologically and developmentally given that axon diameter determines conduction velocity and therefore affects the rate of information transfer along white matter pathways among various brain areas. We developed mathematical models to explain the observed ADDs in different fascicles, suggesting that they represent a balance between maximizing information flow while minimizing metabolic demands. We also developed novel multiple pulsed-field gradient (mPFG) methods and demonstrated their feasibility for use in vivo on conventional clinical MRI scanners as a further means to extract quantitative features to measure and map in the nervous system. The methods provide an independent measurement of mean axon diameter and other features of cell size and shape.
Although gray matter appears featureless in DTI maps, its microstructure and architecture are rich and varied, not only along the brain's cortical surface, but also within and among its different cortical layers. We have been developing several noninvasive, in vivo methods to measure unique features of cortical gray matter microstructure and architecture that are currently invisible in conventional MRI. One goal is to 'parcellate' or segment the cerebral cortex in vivo into its approximately 500 distinct cytoarchitechtonic or Brodmann-like areas. To this end, we are developing advanced MRI sequences to probe correlations among microscopic displacements of water molecules in the neuropil as well as sophisticated mathematical models to infer distinguishing microstructural and morphological features of gray matter that can aid us in the parcellating the cortex. We are continuing to develop such methods, which will permit us to follow normal and abnormal development, and aid in the diagnosis of various diseases and disorders affecting the cerebral cortex, noninvasively and in vivo, and to provide information to help neurosurgeons plan operations and interventions.
Quantitative pediatric MRI
MRI is considered safer for noninvasively scanning pediatric subjects than X-ray–based methods, such as computed tomography (CT). However, clinical MRI still lacks the quantitative character of CT data. Clinical MRI relies upon the acquisition of 'weighted images,' whose contrast is affected by many factors, some intrinsic to the tissue and some dependent on the details of the experiment and experimental design. The diagnostic utility of conventional MRI for many neurological disorders is unquestionable. However, the scope of conventional MRI applications is limited to revealing either gross morphological or focal abnormalities, which result in regional differences in signal intensities within a given tissue. To detect pathology, conventional MRI relies on differences in contrast between areas that are presumed 'affected' and those presumed 'normal,' rendering it intrinsically insensitive to subtle global changes that may affect the entire tissue or organ. Clinical MRI also lacks biological specificity. Although quantification per se does not assure improved specificity, it is nonetheless necessary for developing imaging 'biomarkers.' In particular, the MRI assessment of normal brain development and developmental disorders has benefiting greatly from 'quantitative' clinical MRI techniques, in which one obtains maps of meaningful physical quantities or chemical variables that can be measured in physical units and compared among and between tissue regions, in both longitudinal and cross-sectional studies. Quantitative MRI methods, such as DTI, also increase sensitivity, providing a basis for monitoring subtle changes that occur during the progression or remission of disease by comparing measurements in a single subject against normative values acquired in a healthy population. Quantitative MRI methods should also enhance our ability to perform comparative effectiveness research for a variety of diagnosis and therapy assessments and provide the tools to perform precision imaging studies.
Our group has been carrying out several clinical studies that utilize novel quantitative MRI acquisition and analysis methods, whose aim is to improve accuracy and reproducibility in diagnosis and to detect and follow normal and abnormal development. The studies include the following:
- The NIH Study of Normal Brain Development, jointly sponsored by four NIH Institutes (NICHD, NIMH, NINDS, and NIDA), was a multi-center effort to advance our understanding of normal brain development in typical healthy children and in adolescents. The Brain Development Cooperative Group , created by this mechanism, is still active, publishing numerous papers each year, primarily by mining this rich data set. Structural MRIs and the results of standardized neuropsychological tests performed on this population are also available to researchers outside the consortium. Our role in this interdisciplinary project was to serve as the DTI Data-Processing Center (DPC). While we have now processed all admissible DTI data and uploaded them to a database accessible to all interested investigators, we continue to analyze the data, developing age-specific DTI atlases of normal brain development. We also publicly released various versions of software that we developed for this project (and related documentation), which can be downloaded from http://www.tortoisedti.org . We continue to support and update the software. We are continuing to use our advanced DTI–processing pipeline to produce high-quality normative data from the project, and we make them publicly available through the National Database for Autism Research (NDAR).
- In collaboration with Susan Swedo, we study autistic subjects using DTI and quantitative relaxometry methods. Several MRI studies reported abnormal features in the autistic brain, but no clear MRI 'biomarker' of autism exists. The aim of the study is to use robust quantitative metrics to identify potential anatomical abnormalities in the autistic brain and to find candidate imaging biomarkers for the disorder (an earlier study was described in Walker et al., Biol Psychiatry 2012;72:1043).
- In collaboration with Katherine Warren, we acquire quantitative MRI data in children with pontine gliomas to identify MRI prognostic factors. With John Park, we are scanning subjects with supratentorial gliomas to distinguish between recurrence and radiation necrosis.
- In collaboration with Filippo Arrigoni (http://www.emedea.it/english_medea/ ), we use multimodal MR imaging (DTI, fMRI, and quantitative relaxometry) to evaluate cerebral reorganization caused by various rehabilitation protocols in children with cerebral palsy and traumatic brain injury (TBI). We collected diffusion MRI data on subjects affected by the pure form of hereditary spastic paraparesis, as well as those with additional cognitive impairment. There are remarkable neuroanatomic differences between the two groups.
- We are working under the auspices of the Center for Neuroscience and Regenerative Medicine (CNRM) , to investigate potential plasticity changes after rehabilitation in military personnel affected by TBI and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
- In collaboration with Sharon Juliano, we received grant support from the Congressionally Directed Medical Research Program (CDMRP) to investigate TBI in the ferret, using advanced MRI methods, particularly MAP-MRI, developed within STBB, combined with histopathological techniques provided by Juliano's laboratory. We are currently acquiring MRI data.
Our involvement in TBI research is expanding, because it is of high relevance to the mission of NICHD and because it has become an acute problem in our young military men and women. DTI provides essential information for the diagnosis of TBI and has the potential to be developed into an important tool for the assessment of potential structural damage in PTSD. For clinical applications, however, reliable imaging protocols are needed. Part of our work is to develop a robust DTI data–processing pipeline in order to improve the accuracy and reproducibility of DTI findings for CNRM investigators and for the larger clinical and scientific community involved in TBI research. To this end, we are adding new modules to our existing state-of-the-art DTI data–processing pipeline as well as tools to permit calibration of DTI experiments, using our novel polymer-based diffusion MRI phantom that we developed and are disseminating to a number of clinical sites.
Dr. BUDDI, our group's new method for correcting distortion caused by the diffusion weighted Echo-Planar Imaging (EPI) acquisition, is juxtaposed with two other widely used methods for correcting these artifacts. While T2-weighted images (top row) look fairly similar in the pons, there are significant artifacts in the white matter architecture within this structure (bottom row) when employing two widely used distortion-correction schemes. Topup shows three sensory pathways rather than two; EPIC causes the two known sensory pathways to coalesce into one. Dr. BUDDI preserves the two known neuroanatomical structures in this important brain region and generally out-performs other methods available to address this important imaging artifact. Dr. BUBBI is one of the methods we are developing to advance the field of quantitative imaging.
Looking ahead, to permit analysis of novel MRI data such as those described above, as well as to develop new clinical and biological applications of quantitative MRI, we need to create a mathematical, statistical, and image sciences–based infrastructure. To date, we have developed algorithms that generate a continuous, smooth approximation of the discrete, noisy, measured DTI field data so as to reduce noise and allow us to follow fiber tracts more reliably. We proposed a novel Gaussian distribution for tensor-valued random variables that we used in designing optimal DTI experiments and interpreting their results. In tandem, we developed nonparametric empirical (e.g., Bootstrap) methods for determining the statistical distribution of DTI–derived quantities in order to study, for example, the inherent variability and reliability of white-matter fiber-tract trajectories. Such parametric and nonparametric statistical methods will enable us to apply powerful hypothesis tests to assess statistical significance in a wide range of important biological and clinical questions that are currently being addressed using ad hoc statistical methods. We are also developing novel methods to register or warp different brain volumes, and to generate group-average data or atlases from subject populations.
Recently, our group has been developing methods for studying the reproducibility and reliability of different tractography methods, given that, increasingly, they are being used to assess anatomical connections between different brain regions in vivo. In the area of artifact remediation and correction, we pioneered methods to correct for subject motion, the distortion caused by induced eddy-currents, echo-planar imaging (EPI) distortion. However, much work remains to be done in order to address and remedy MRI artifacts to permit one to draw statistically significant inferences from clinical DTI data, obtained in longitudinal and multi-center studies but particularly in single subject studies.
Prospective Motion Correction (PROMO)–enabled MP2RAGE MRI methods we are developing successfully correct for subject motion in the scanner. Without PROMO, subject motion generates significant artifacts that degrade spatial accuracy and tissue contrasts. Clearly, the method has promise in scanning pediatric subjects, who often have difficulty remaining still in the scanner.
Biopolymer physics: water-ion-biopolymer interactions
Molecular self-organization is ubiquitous in biology. Examples include DNA nanostructure formation and protein folding. Self-assembly of aberrant proteins into nanofibers is associated with neurodegenerative conditions, such as Creutzfeldt-Jakob, Alzheimer’s, and Pick’s disease. One objective of this research is to better understand self-assembly of biomolecules from a physical perspective by studying, primarily in polynucleic acids and proteins, particularly the interactions between water, ions, and the biopolymer.
By combining macroscopic osmotic swelling pressure measurements and small-angle scattering measurements, we developed a multi-scale experimental approach to study the structure (morphology) and thermodynamic interactions in biopolymer assemblies as a function of the length scale (spatial resolution). Swelling pressure measurements probe the system at large (macroscopic) length scales, providing information on its overall thermodynamic response, while SANS and SAXS allow us to investigate biopolymers at the atomic and molecular levels. Measurements of physical properties, such as molecular conformation and osmotic pressure, as a function of changes in environmental conditions, such as ion concentration, ion valance, pH, and temperature, all help us uncover which length scales govern the system's key macroscopic thermodynamic properties. The information cannot be obtained by other techniques.
Divalent cations, particularly calcium ions, are ubiquitous in the biological milieu. However, existing theories of polyelectolyte solutions and gels do not adequately explain or account for their effects on, or interactions with, charged macromolecules. In pilot studies, we used our new non-destructive procedures to determine the effect of calcium ions on the physical properties of hyaluronic acid (HA) and DNA gels. The gel systems mimic certain essential features of the extracellular matrix (ECM) and have potential as scaffolds for tissue-regeneration applications. We investigated the binding mechanism in glucose sensors made from smart zwitterionic hydrogels containing boronic acid moieties. Our combined SANS and osmotic pressure measurements provided a thermodynamic explanation for the enhanced selectivity of the gels for glucose over fructose. This class of material is important for the development of implantable continuous glucose sensors intended for use in managing Type I and Type II diabetes.
We also developed a method to control the size, compactness, and stability of DNA nano-particles by mediating their interactions with ions. We quantified the effects of salt, pH, and temperature on the stability of the nano-particles and on their biological activity. Such polyplexes are pathogen-like particles, 70–300 nm in size, with shapes resembling the spherical viruses that evolved naturally to deliver nucleic acids to cells. The nano-particles contain pDNA encapsulated by synthetic polymers bearing surface sugar residues, which are recognized by "M" cells and dendritic cells as pathogens. The biological activity of such nano-medicines depends on the competing requirements of sufficient stability to escape endosomal degradation after cellular uptake and retention of biological activity upon arrival in the nucleus, where the nano-particle releases the pDNA to achieve gene expression. Such knowledge is essential to design and control properties of DNA–based nano-medicines. DNA–based vaccines are promising in several disease indications and have potential applications in the treatment of infectious diseases, cancers, and allergies. We studied nano-structures formed from small gelator molecules via enzyme-assisted self-assembly inside live cells. The gelator molecule consists of a self-assembly motif and an enzyme (phosphatase) substrate (tyrosine phosphorous ester). After the enzymatic reaction removes the phosphorous group, intermolecular interactions facilitate the self-assembly of the molecules, leading them to form nano-fibers. The approach offers a new way to control cell behavior. For example, intracellular formation of molecular assemblies could be used to selectively inhibit the growth of cells that over-express certain enzymes. Developing molecular self-assembly–based approaches and exploring their potential applications in biomedicine (e.g., intracellular drug delivery) may ultimately lead to new ways to regulate cell functions.
Functional properties of extracellular matrix
Our goal is to understand and quantify the interactions among the major macromolecular components of ECM that give rise to their key functional properties. Specifically, we are studying interactions among collagen, proteoglycans (PG), water, and ions, which govern macroscopic biomechanical and transport properties, using cartilage as a model system. The biomechanical behavior of cartilage and other ECMs reflects both biochemical and microstructural changes occurring during development, disease, degeneration, and aging. Understanding the basis of key functional properties of cartilage requires an array of experimental techniques that probe a wide range of relevant length and time scales. Knowledge of the physical and chemical mechanisms affecting cartilage swelling (hydration) is essential for predicting its load-bearing and lubricating abilities, which are mainly governed by osmotic and electrostatic forces. The knowledge can aid in tissue-engineering or regenerative-medicine strategies to grow, repair, and reintegrate replacement cartilage. To gain a self-consistent physical picture of tissue structure/function relationships, we measure various physical/chemical properties of tissues and tissue analogs at different length- and time-scales using a variety of complementary static and dynamic experimental techniques, e.g., osmometry, SANS, SAXS, neutron spin-echo (NSE), SLS, DLS, AFM, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS).
Controlled tissue hydration provides a direct means of determining the patency and load-bearing ability of cartilage. Previously, we used controlled hydration to measure physical/chemical properties of the collagen network and of proteoglycans. We developed and built a novel tissue micro-osmometer to perform swelling pressure measurements in a practical, rapid, and automated manner. The instrument measures minute amounts of water vapor absorbed by small tissue samples (less than 1 microgram) as a function of the water activity (vapor pressure). A quartz crystal detects the water uptake of the tissue specimen. The high sensitivity of the quartz crystal's resonance frequency to small changes in the amount of adsorbed water allows us to measure mass uptake precisely. We use osmotic pressure measurements to determine the contributions of individual components of cartilage ECM (e.g., aggrecan, hyaluronic acid [HA], and collagen) to the total tissue-swelling pressure. Our measurements on aggrecan–HA systems revealed that, in the physiological concentration range, the osmotic modulus of the aggrecan–HA complex exceeds that of random assemblies of aggrecan bottlebrushes, providing direct evidence that the aggrecan–HA complex could increase the load-bearing ability of cartilage. In addition, we demonstrated that aggrecan–HA assemblies behave like microgels, contributing to improved dimensional stability and tissue-lubricating ability. We also found that aggrecan is highly insensitive to changes in the ionic environment, particularly to Ca2+ ions. The latter result is consistent aggrecan's role as a calcium ion reservoir mediating calcium metabolism in cartilage and bone.
We also developed a novel method for mapping the local elastic properties of cartilage (and other heterogeneous tissues) using AFM. Many impediments that previously hindered AFM's use to probe biological samples were addressed. The technique utilizes the precise scanning capabilities of AFM to generate compliance 'maps,' from which the relevant elastic properties can be extracted. We combined AFM with tissue micro-osmometry to produce elastic and osmotic modulus maps of cartilage. The results clearly show that the spatial variation of the osmotic modulus is similar to that of the elastic (shear) modulus but that the modulus's numerical value is significantly greater. Knowledge of the osmotic modulus is particularly important because it determines the tissue's resistance to external compressive loads.
We have begun applying such critical tissue-sciences understanding of structure/function relationships of components of ECM to develop and design novel MR imaging methods with the aim of inferring ECM patency and functional properties non-invasively and in vivo. This extremely challenging goal is aided by our receipt of a DIR Director's Award to investigate this proposed line of research. Specifically, we are developing a family of imaging methods directed at measuring key compositional and structural features of cartilage ECM, which we can use to estimate functional properties of the tissue with the aid of a biophysical modeling framework.
- Award 305500-1.01-60855 from the Henry Jackson Foundation supports STBB's project in "Enhanced Software Tools for the Analysis of Diffusion MRI in TBI and PTSD," which is under the joint auspices of the NIH, DoD, CNRM, and USUHS.
- Award 306135-2.01-60855 from the Henry Jackson Foundation supports STBB's project "Clinical Double Pulsed-Field Gradient (dPFG) MRI for Mild TBI Assessment," which is under the joint auspices of the NIH, DoD, CNRM, and USUHS.